top of page

Are We Ready, or Are We Just Rolling?

Catherine Addor
3 hours ago
4 min read

I am sitting in a visual arts film production class listening to students formally critique one another’s short films.


They are talking about framing, pacing, lighting, sound, editing, storytelling, and the choices that shaped the final product. Then I heard a sentence that immediately moved beyond filmmaking for me:


“Preproduction is often where everything goes right.”


That may be one of the best descriptions of effective leadership I have heard in a while.


In film, preproduction happens before the camera starts rolling. It is where people determine the purpose, plan the shots, think through the setting, anticipate the logistics, clarify roles, gather what they need, and make decisions that will influence everything that follows.


The finished film may be what everyone sees.


Much of its success was decided long before anyone pressed record.


Leadership is often the same.


We tend to notice leadership in the visible moments: the meeting, the rollout, the announcement, the professional development day, the new initiative, the difficult conversation, the community presentation, the implementation.


Strong leadership frequently happens before any of those things.


It happens in the thinking.


Who needs to be involved?

What are we actually trying to accomplish?

What information do people need before we begin?

Where could this go sideways?

Whose perspective have we not yet considered?

What structures need to exist before we ask people to change their practice?

What will people reasonably misunderstand if we do not explain it?

What resources, time, training, authority, or support will be necessary?


And perhaps most importantly:

Have we prepared people for the work, or have we simply prepared the work for people?


There is a difference.


Poor planning often gets disguised as an implementation problem.


An initiative struggles, and we assume people are resistant.

A meeting becomes contentious, and we assume people are difficult.

A new procedure is inconsistently followed, and we assume people are unwilling.

A team misses expectations, and we assume accountability is the problem.


Those things can sometimes be true. Sometimes the camera rolls before the organization finishes preproduction.


Leadership cannot anticipate every variable. Schools are human systems, and human systems are wonderfully unpredictable.


We can dramatically improve our chances of success by spending more time designing the conditions around the work.


Before launching the next initiative, having the next difficult conversation, or asking people to change course, it is worth examining what happened before the visible work began. These questions can help determine whether you are truly ready to move forward or simply eager to get started.


  • What does success actually look like, and can everyone involved describe it the same way?

  • Who needs to have a voice before decisions are finalized?

  • What assumptions am I making about what people already know?

  • What barriers can I reasonably anticipate now?

  • Are expectations, responsibilities, and decision-making authority clear?

  • What resources or support will people need to do this well?

  • Where might uncertainty create confusion rather than productive thinking?

  • What communication needs to happen before implementation begins?

  • What feedback should be gathered while there is still time to change the plan?

  • Am I preparing people to succeed, or preparing myself to announce that we are beginning


Better preproduction does not require creating a forty-page implementation plan for every decision. It requires becoming more intentional about the small leadership moves that happen before the work becomes public.


  • Define the ending before designing the beginning.

    • Clearly articulate what you are trying to accomplish, what you hope will be different, and how you will recognize meaningful progress.

  • Bring the right people into the room early.

    • Consulting after a decision is made is not the same as participating in planning. Seek perspective while that perspective can still influence the work.

  • Do a pre-mortem.

    • Ask, “If this goes badly three months from now, what probably happened?” Then address the most predictable problems before they become real ones.

  • Clarify roles before activity begins.

    • People should know who is leading, who is contributing, who is deciding, who is supporting, and what responsibility belongs to them.

  • Plan the communication, not just the initiative.

    • Determine what people need to hear, when they need to hear it, why it matters to them, and where they can ask questions.

  • Build in rehearsal.

    • Pilot the process. Test the agenda. Walk through the conversation. Ask someone outside the planning team what they think the message means. Small rehearsals expose large problems.

  • Protect space for revision.

    • Good planning is not about proving the original idea was perfect. It is about discovering what needs to change while it is still relatively easy to change.

  • Make support part of the launch.

    • Don't announce a new expectation and then start looking for the training, time, tools, or coaching people will need. Build those supports into the plan from the beginning.


Leadership can be tempted to admire action.


We celebrate the person who gets things moving, makes decisions, launches initiatives, and keeps everyone focused on execution.


Action matters.


Movement is not the same thing as progress.


Some of the most important leadership work will never be visible to the people who eventually experience its results. It is the conversation before the meeting. The listening before the announcement. The question asked before the decision. The scenario considered before the rollout. The relationship built before the difficult moment arrives.


Maybe leadership, like filmmaking, gets stronger when we stop treating planning as something that delays the real work.


Preproduction is often where everything goes right.


Perhaps one of the most innovative things a leader can do is ensure the organization is ready before calling, “Action.”


Comments


bottom of page